B.B. Saxena

ResearchCaseUnsolved

An Indian boy from Bareilly, born with blond hair and fair skin, who in the 1920s said he had been an English soldier named Arthur, shot in the neck on horseback in the First World War; he had a birthmark like a bullet wound on his neck and English habits, but the soldier was never identified.

Overview

Bajrang Bahadur Saxena, known as B. B. Saxena, was born in Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh, probably in 1918, the fourth of eight children of Ram Charan Lal, a law clerk of the Kayasth subcaste, and his wife Sudama Kunwar. Neither parent spoke English. He was born with almost white blond hair and a pink complexion, though his eyes were brown, and with a round red birthmark on the right side of his neck.1

Between the ages of three and four he began to say that he had been a white soldier named Arthur who died in the ‘German war’, the First World War. His parents believed that a child who remembers a past life will die young and tried to stop him, so few details survive, and no soldier matching them was ever identified.12

What he said

The earliest record is a short account by K.K.N. Sahay, a Bareilly lawyer whose own son had remembered a previous life, in a booklet of cases he printed privately in about 1927. Sahay wrote that the boy called himself Arthur, a white soldier who had died at 28, with a mother and two brothers and a father long dead. When a second fair-skinned son, Brij Bahadur, was born, he said this was his second brother from that life. By the time Sahay wrote, the boy had forgotten his story.2

Decades later his older sister and brother recalled that he spoke of an English wife and a house with a kitchen and a cook, unlike his own home, and said he had been on horseback in a battle when a bullet hit him in the neck; his sister said he pointed to his birthmark as he said it, though both siblings remembered him indicating the left side. He gave no surname and never said where he had lived or fought.1

Behaviour

From about three he played at soldiers, drilling and calling out ‘Left, right’ and ‘March’, using a stick as a rifle and asking for a real gun, though no one in his family had been a soldier. He played leapfrog, a game unfamiliar in India, wanted shirts, shorts and shoes, preferred white clothes, and told his mother her sari was the wrong shape and colour. He asked for a knife and fork, for meat in a vegetarian home, for bread and butter instead of chapatis, and for boiled vegetables without chillies.12

He complained of the heat and the dirt of the neighbourhood, called the house strange and looked for his ‘proper house’, longed for his wife and wanted to see his brother from that life. He was domineering, often sad, disliked Hindu worship and felt a stranger at home. His family heard him use words they thought might be English, and he learned English easily. As a young man he refused the brides chosen for him and at 30 married an educated woman of another caste.1

Birthmarks

As photographed in 1969, the neck mark was a roundish red patch about 2.5 centimetres across on the right side, slightly depressed in the centre, with a paler rim that Stevenson compared to the ring of abraded skin around a gunshot entry wound. His sister said it looked like raw flesh at birth. Sahay also recorded a second mark, on the head, and photographs show a hairless, puckered patch of similar size on the right side of the scalp, but the sister and brother did not remember it, so Stevenson left its status in doubt. If it was a birthmark, he thought it might correspond to an exit wound, which would need an unusual bullet path, or to a second wound.12

His fair colouring amounted to partial albinism: he was sensitive to glare and wore dark glasses in bright sun. Stevenson cautioned that albinos generally feel the heat, so that complaint need not be an English trait.1

Investigation

Sahay’s booklet reached an English family named Phillips, and one of them visited the Saxenas when B. B. was about eight. He said his brother had been killed by a bullet in the neck while riding in battle, and offered a pension if he could adopt the boy. Ram Charan Lal refused, and B. B. did not recognize the visitor. Whether the brother was called Arthur is not known, and the visit is known only from the older sister, who heard of it soon afterwards.1

Ian Stevenson met B. B. Saxena in 1961 and interviewed him repeatedly until 1977, assisted by Francis Story, Jamuna Prasad and L. P. Mehrotra. He also interviewed his wife, his younger brother and, separately, his older sister Munni Devi and brother Shamsur Bahadur Varma, who were in or near their teens at the time and whose accounts closely agreed. Stevenson judged them responsible witnesses.1

Assessment and later life

Bareilly had a British army base, but the European community was tiny and kept apart. The family had no British friends and saw Europeans only occasionally at a fair, and the father dealt with British judges in Hindi. The family thought the boy might have picked up English drill commands from the army. Stevenson noted that nothing in the case could be verified and that the parents may have stopped the boy from saying more.1

As an adult B. B. took an MA, studied journalism and worked in Delhi. He said he had no memories left of the previous life, had been an ardent follower of Gandhi from 1934 to 1950, criticized British rule and doubted reincarnation. Yet he still preferred a cool climate, bread to rice and European food, ate with cutlery, kept a dog and stayed unruffled in a riot and after a fatal car accident, which reminded Stevenson’s Indian colleagues of British composure. He had no interest in military matters and no fear of guns.1

Verification highlights

StatementRecorded before contact?Outcome
His name was ArthurYesNot checked
He had been a white soldier who died in the German warYesNot checked
He was 28 when he diedYesNot checked
He was shot in the neck while on horseback in a battleYesNot checked
He had a mother and two brothers, and his father had died long beforeYesNot checked
His fair-skinned baby brother had been his second brother in that lifeYesNot checked
He had an English wifeYesNot checked
He had lived in a house with a kitchen and employed a cookYesNot checked

Sources

  1. Stevenson, I. (1997). Reincarnation and biology, vol. 2. Praeger. Find a copy (opens in a new tab)
  2. Sahay, K. K. N. (1927). Reincarnation: Verified cases of rebirth after death. Gupta. Find a copy (opens in a new tab)
Know a source we’ve missed?Send us a paper, book or document about this subject and our editors will review it. Suggest a source
Cite this entry: ICRR Compendium. “B.B. Saxena (reincarnation case).” Last modified 21 October 2026. reincarnationcentre.org/compendium/b-b-saxena/