Overview
Lekh Pal Jatav was born in Nagla Devi in December 1971, a village in the Mainpuri District of Uttar Pradesh, the sixth of eight children of poor, illiterate cultivators. He was born without the finger bones of his right hand, and someone half-jokingly said he must have been a tax collector whose fingers an angry taxpayer cut off. The Hindi phrase for a tax collector is lekh pal, and his parents gave him the name.1

A long illness slowed his development, and he did not speak fully until five. By about one he was repeating ‘Tal, Tal’ and saying he was from ‘Tal Gaon’. To his older sister, who looked after him, he said this was not his home, and described cutting his hand in a fodder-chopping machine.1
Hukum Singh
At a wedding when Lekh Pal was still a baby, a woman from Nagla Tal, about 8 kilometres away, saw his hand and told his mother that a boy back home, Hukum Singh, had a hand like it. Hukum Singh, at about three and a half, had put his right hand into the blades of a fodder machine his father was working alone, and lost his fingers. The hand healed. About ten months later he died of a sudden fever while his father carried him home. His mother was inconsolable, and twice dreamed in the following two months that he told her he would come back to her.1
Stevenson and Satwant Pasricha searched about 1,500 hospital register entries but found no record of the accident, and the parents could not give the year of death, so the gap between the lives is not firmly known.1
Statements and recognitions
Lekh Pal never gave Hukum Singh’s name. He said he had worked the machine with his ‘chacha’, which means uncle, a word the family used for Hukum Singh’s father. Two details were wrong: he said he was taken to Fatehgarh and died of the injury. When Hukum Singh’s brothers came to a wedding in Nagla Devi he went indoors, but later, when asked, called one ‘my brother’. He kept running away toward Nagla Tal, and when taken there he identified the place of the accident and the place where Hukum Singh died. Stevenson thought his recognitions of the family were weak, as he had been asked leading questions such as ‘Who is your mother?’1
The birth defect
In 1980 Lekh Pal’s left hand was normal, while the right had short, boneless stubs, some with small nails, and x-rays in 1983 confirmed the missing bones. No relatives within two generations had a birth defect. Stevenson called this brachydactyly but stressed how unusual it was: the known form affects both hands and occurs in about 1 in 40,000 births, whereas one-sided cases are exceedingly rare, and in ordinary forms the fingers are short rather than almost absent.1
One mismatch remained. Lekh Pal’s thumb was affected as much as his fingers, yet Hukum Singh’s family insisted his thumb had not been cut. Stevenson pressed them, and could not resolve it.1
Later life
The families became friends. Lekh Pal stayed with Hukum Singh’s family at times and brought rice to his mother; earlier he had said he must go because she would be alone. He showed no fear of fodder machines and helped with them on the farm. At 18 he said he had no memories left of his own, only what he had been told, and was working in the family’s fields, where the hand was a handicap. Hukum Singh’s mother still regarded him as her son. The case is told in the fourth episode of The Reincarnation Records.12