Overview
Thiang San Kla was born on 9 October 1924 at Ban Rasai in Surin Province, Thailand. His aunt said both his parents had dreamed before his birth that his father’s older brother, Phoh, came to them and said he wished to live with them. Phoh had been killed about a year earlier. Relatives saw marks on the baby’s head and right great toe within days and, with the dreams, took him to be Phoh reborn.1

As soon as he could talk he said he was Phoh, called his father ‘brother’, and grew angry when addressed by a baby’s nickname. Because this all happened inside one family, Stevenson stressed that his parents knew everything he said about Phoh and could have passed it on.1
Phoh San Kla
Phoh, born around 1889, was a notorious cattle thief. In October 1923 he and a friend went to Ban Ar Vud to see a bull. Villagers who knew his record decided to finish with him, and a group attacked him. One struck the back of his head with a heavy knife of the sort used for coconuts and firewood, probably killing him at once. Some time before, he had hurt his right foot, and the great toe stayed infected until he died.1
Recognitions
At four or five he greeted by name the former policeman who had investigated Phoh, and named people involved in the killing. According to Thiang himself, Phoh’s widow then tested him at five, with Phoh’s belongings mixed among others, and he sorted them correctly. At seven he spontaneously hailed Phoh’s daughter on the road, surprising her, since she had been living in Cambodia, and convinced her with what he knew of her father’s life. As an adult in the army he laid claim to land by the camp, which had indeed been Phoh’s, though he was told a court would not allow it.12
Birth defects
The main mark was a raised, wrinkled, hairless, dark growth about 5 to 6 centimetres long at the back left of his head, which Stevenson examined in 1969. The nail of his right great toe was partly detached and dark. An uncle and an aunt said they saw both within days of the birth. The policeman and the same uncle, who had both seen Phoh’s wound, said the head mark matched it. Thiang also described birthmarks matching tattoos on Phoh’s hands and feet that had faded by age seven, but only he reported those.1
Revenge and reform
As a boy Thiang was angry with the villagers who killed Phoh, and at 45 he still sometimes pictured going back for revenge. He said he had come to see that Phoh’s conduct had led to his death, and resolved to live differently. He became a sergeant and then a village headman, whose job included dealing with thieves, and on the morning Stevenson arrived he was chasing men who had stolen his own cattle. Phoh’s daughter described the change as one from thief to good man. When his uncle punished him for talking of the past life, leaving burn scars still visible in 1969, it stopped him talking but not remembering.1
Assessment
Story learned of the case in 1963, and nothing was written down until more than 35 years after the events, by which time both parents had died. Stevenson accepted that Thiang had convinced several adults as a child, but regarded the two defects as the most important evidence. He did not rule out a maternal impression, since Thiang’s mother had seen the body. Thiang also described seeing Phoh’s body after death and visiting relatives unseen before entering his mother.1 The case is told in the fourth episode of The Reincarnation Records.3