Overview
Shanti Devi was born on 11 December 1926 into a middle-class family in Delhi.1 From about four she talked of her ‘husband’ and ‘children’ in Mathura, some 145 kilometres away, a town neither she nor her parents had visited. She said she had been Lugdi, the wife of a Chaubey, and described her home and her husband’s shop.1 According to K.S. Rawat, she said the cloth shop faced the Dwarkadhish temple and that her husband was fair, with a large wart on his left cheek, and wore reading glasses. She also described dying after childbirth, in detail that surprised the family doctor.3
Identification
Rawat gives Lugdi’s dates as 18 January 1902 to 4 October 1925. Married at ten to Kedar Nath Chaubey, a widower with a cloth shop in Mathura, she had a stillborn first child; her second, a son, was born by Caesarean section in Agra on 25 September 1925, and she died nine days later, about fourteen months before Shanti Devi was born.3
Shanti Devi would not say her husband’s name, as Indian wives customarily avoid it, until a great-uncle, Bishan Chand, promised to take her to Mathura if she whispered it. A letter setting out her statements went to Kedar Nath, who replied that most were correct.34 His younger cousin Kanji Mal, who lived in Delhi, then visited; she recognized him and told him where she had hidden money in Mathura.13
Kedar Nath visited on 13 November 1935 with his third wife and Lugdi’s son, Navneet Lal. Introduced to her as Kedar Nath’s elder brother, he was identified by Shanti Devi as her husband, and she reminded her mother of the wart she had described. She named his favourite dishes, mentioned a well in the courtyard where she used to bathe, and hugged the boy in tears.3 After questioning her alone about intimate matters, he was convinced that she was Lugdi.13
The committee's visit to Mathura
Mahatma Gandhi met Shanti Devi, and on his advice a committee of fifteen prominent people, including politicians and journalists, was formed to test her claims; Rawat and Titus Rivas describe it as the first of its kind.13 Manly P. Hall names three of its members: the newspaper director Lala Deshbandhu Gupta, the Congress leader N.R. Sharma and the lawyer T.C. Mathur. He says their report concluded that her story was entirely genuine.24 On 24 November 1935 the committee took her to Mathura, and Rawat and Rivas write that it watched her closely and noted all her movements and remarks.12
According to the committee’s report as quoted by Rawat, on the platform she touched the feet of an older man in local dress and whispered that he was her husband’s elder brother. He was indeed Kedar Nath’s elder brother, Babu Ram Chaubey.23 Directing a tonga, she pointed out changes since her time, bowed to her former father-in-law in the crowd, found Lugdi’s room, and passed a test on two words used only by the Chaubeys of Mathura.3 Hall adds that she knew the house although it had been repainted, and had used the Mathura idiom before she ever went there.4
At the other house where Lugdi had lived, she could not find the well she had mentioned but insisted it was there, and Kedar Nath lifted a stone to reveal it. The place where she said she had hidden money was empty, but she insisted it had been there, and Kedar Nath later admitted taking it after Lugdi’s death.34 At the home of Lugdi’s parents, Rawat writes, she first took an aunt for her mother before correcting herself; Hall says she picked out the parents at once from more than fifty people.34
Later investigations
In February 1936 the rationalist B.C. Nahata questioned her and concluded in a Hindi booklet that the evidence did not show she remembered a former life; the philosopher Indra Sen replied that Nahata had drawn firm conclusions from very little.1 On an unpublicized second visit to Mathura in April 1936, most of her statements were again correct, though at Vrindaban she said one floor was of red and white tiles when it was black and white.3 Sen, who tested her on new points and arranged a hypnosis session on 13 April 1936, was confident she had memories that were not of the ‘here and now’.13
Sushil Bose interviewed her, her father and Kedar Nath, and published the interviews in 1952 without comment.1 Ian Stevenson studied the sources in 1961; Rawat quotes him as saying he also interviewed Shanti Devi, her father and Kedar Nath, and that at least 24 of her statements matched the verified facts.13 Rawat himself interviewed her from February 1986, the first time with Stevenson and Satwant Pasricha, as well as her younger brother and Lugdi’s relatives.13
Memories of the time between lives
Shanti Devi also described the time between Lugdi’s death and her own birth, and Rawat and Rivas compared five records of it made between 1936 and 1987.1 She spoke of darkness and then a dazzling light, of leaving her body and of being carried upward in a small vessel by three or four young men in yellow or saffron robes, past a river she likened to milk, to a fourth plane where a radiant figure on a throne reviewed each person’s deeds. She called him Krishna in 1936, but when asked in 1986 whether it was Krishna or Chitragupta, the recorder of deeds in Hindu belief, she chose Chitragupta. She was then brought down a staircase of gold and silver to a dark cell, where she felt no hunger or thirst.1
Assessment and later life
Rawat and Rivas note that neither she nor her parents had been to Mathura.1 Hall argued that she could not have been reading Kedar Nath’s mind, since she insisted the money was there when he knew he had taken it, and saw reincarnation as the only reasonable explanation.4 The Swedish critic Sture Lönnerstrand came to India to expose the case and ended by calling it fully proven, a view Rawat does not entirely share.13
Rawat cautioned that the case may not be foolproof: Sen admitted in 1938 that he could not watch the girl continuously, the publicity made it hard to tell which statements were her own and which might have come from others, and there were discrepancies. Against this, he noted that she had never been to Mathura before and recognized many of Lugdi’s relatives on her own.3 She kept her memories into adulthood, discussing them with Rawat until shortly before her death on 27 December 1987.13