Overview
Maria Januaria de Oliveira, known as Sinhá, was born about 1890 to a prosperous rancher whose fazenda lay twelve miles west of Dom Feliciano in Rio Grande do Sul, southern Brazil. Her close friend in the village was Ida Lorenz, wife of the schoolteacher F. V. Lorenz. Twice her father opposed her marrying a man she loved, and the second, Florzinho, killed himself. Sinhá then deliberately exposed herself to cold and damp, and developed tuberculosis of the larynx and lungs.1
On her deathbed she admitted to Ida that she had wanted to die, and promised to be reborn as Ida’s daughter, adding that once she could talk she would tell of her present life so that Ida would know her. She died the next day, in October 1917, aged about 28. Ten months later, on 14 August 1918, Ida gave birth to Marta.1
First statements
At about two and a half, walking home from the stream with her older sister Lola, Marta asked to be carried, saying that when she was big and Lola small she had often carried her. She described a place far away with cows, oxen, oranges and animals that were like goats but not goats. Her father took these to be sheep, which she had never seen; Sinhá’s family kept sheep, the Lorenz family only goats.12
Questioned at home, she said she had had other parents then, and that her father there had beaten a small servant boy for forgetting to fetch water until she begged him to stop. The water, she said, came from a well, not a stream, which was true of Sinhá’s home. Asked who Sinhá was, she said it had been herself, and that she had also been called Maria and a third name she could not recall. By her own later account, her father then suggested Januaria and she agreed.12
Investigation
F. V. Lorenz noted about 120 statements and recognitions in German shorthand, but a relative who could not read the notes threw them away, and he later wrote his recollections from memory in a book published in 1946 by the Brazilian Spiritist Federation.2 Ian Stevenson investigated in July 1962, after Lorenz, Ida and Sinhá’s father had all died. Besides Lorenz’s book and fuller notes, he interviewed nine witnesses: Marta, five of her siblings, two foster sisters and Sinhá’s surviving sister, Dona Moça Costa. He tabulated 28 items, omitting discrepant or unverified testimony unless he commented on it. Most items were known to someone in the Lorenz household, sometimes only to Ida, but six had to be checked with outsiders.1
Recognitions
Of those six, the beating of the servant boy was confirmed by Sinhá’s father. Marta picked out a man, Florinda de Almeida, as Sinhá’s former sweetheart, which he admitted. When Francisca de Oliveira, a stranger in Dom Feliciano, challenged her to say how they were related, Marta answered correctly that Francisca was Sinhá’s cousin and goddaughter. She also said that Sinhá had sat next to her father at meals, which the Lorenz parents did not know, and that the two cows Sinhá gave her godson Carlos Lorenz had calved; Lorenz’s notes said one had, while Lola and Marta said both. Her statement that Sinhá was buried in white with something on her head was never verified.1
Marta’s father took her to Sinhá’s home only when she was twelve. There she described a turn in the road round a large stone and pointed to a clock, saying it had been Sinhá’s and had her name in gold on the back. Sinhá’s father reluctantly took it down, and the name was there. The only witnesses Stevenson could reach were Marta and Waldomiro, who had the story from their father; in 1962 Sinhá’s surviving relatives could not remember the clock.1
Behaviour and illness
Marta identified with Sinhá while remaining herself, often beginning ‘When I was Sinhá’, and as a small child told a grieving visitor that she too had died and was living again. Like Sinhá, she loved cats and dancing and was afraid of rain and of blood. Waldomiro said no one else in the family had the blood phobia, and a woman who had known Sinhá, and knew nothing of Marta’s claim, said Marta reacted to a bleeding finger just as Sinhá had. Stevenson noted that most observers knew of Marta’s claim and that some of these traits are common.1
Sinhá could only whisper in her last days, and when Ida asked how she had last spoken, Marta leaned to her mother’s ear, whispered, and pointed at her throat. Until about ten Marta had frequent throat infections that made her voice harsh, and in 1972 she still lost her voice with bronchitis about four times a year, unlike any of her siblings. Stevenson thought this might be considered a kind of ‘internal birthmark’.1
Assessment
With the families so close, Stevenson thought it likely that some information reached Marta normally, and asked whether that could explain all of it. The parents had kept Sinhá’s promise from their children, who said they had not known of it before Marta began to speak, and Lorenz’s record of the first conversation shows him asking rather than suggesting. Stevenson granted that parents who wanted their friend back might have encouraged Marta’s identification with her, but thought this view had weaknesses as well as merit.1
He also took extrasensory perception seriously. Sinhá was said to sense in advance when Ida would visit, and at five or six Marta woke describing a vision of a girl named Celica calling her ‘Sinhá’, at what proved to be the time of Celica’s death some fifteen miles away. Celica had been Sinhá’s friend. Stevenson conceded that ESP could not be ruled out in this case.1
Later life
Marta married Fritz Huber and lived in Porto Alegre. Meeting her again in 1972, at 54, Stevenson felt he had overstated the fading of her memories: she still recalled Sinhá’s last illness clearly, still thought of herself as Sinhá as well as Marta, and believed her first two sons, who died as babies, had been Florzinho reborn. Her younger brother Paulo, the subject of another case in the same book, killed himself in 1966, and Carlos died about 1969. She told Stevenson she had often wished to die but had never tried to take her own life.1